On November 9, 2025, Skippers Seafood closed its Old Saybrook location at 688 Boston Post Road for renovation. A year later the same family had the building open again as EōS Greek Bowls & Pitas, a fast-casual Greek counter, while the Niantic Skippers kept serving seafood. Most of Old Saybrook's restaurant news this year looks like that. A familiar address gets a new owner, a new menu, or a new reason to stop in. Very little of it involved new buildings, and the largest project in town review is also a return to a site the town already knows.
That pattern runs from Main Street to the Post Road and out to Saybrook Point, and it is a useful way to plan this winter's meals.
A butcher counter in the James Pharmacy
The building at 323 Main Street went up in 1820. It was the pharmacy of Ann Petry, the first African-American woman pharmacist in Connecticut, and it later held a string of restaurants, including Cocotte, Caffe Marche and Tissa's Le Souk Du Maroc.
This summer it reopened under Chef Colt Taylor, who also owns The Essex restaurant in Old Saybrook. The Connecticut Scoop reported in July that the James is now a butcher shop, sandwich counter, ice cream parlor and provisions market. It sells house-made sausage, Prime and Wagyu beef, rotisserie chickens, small-batch ice cream, and a shelf of Japanese chef knives and cookware. Most of what the James sells is meant to go home with you, from Wagyu for the grill to a rotisserie chicken for a weeknight.
The James is closed Mondays. It is open Tuesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. For a sit-down meal from the same chef, The Essex serves dinner Tuesday through Thursday from 4 to 8 p.m. and Friday and Saturday until 8:30, and it takes reservations.
Same rooms, new hands along the Post Road
EōS has the same quick-stop role that Skippers had on Boston Post Road, with a different menu. It was soft-open by early November, held a grand opening on Sunday, November 15, and lists daily hours of 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. A spring forecast in the New Haven Register had expected a June opening, so the counter arrived about five months later than planned and right as the off-season started.
A little farther east, at 855 Boston Post Road, Fenwick Ice Cream Co. has new owners. The Connecticut Scoop reported in late July that Ben Waterbury and Erin Gray had taken over from the shop's retiring owner. Off the Post Road, Mill Rock Gathering Pizzeria & Cucina at 45 Mill Rock Road East reopened in July under Cast Iron Chef management. Its website has a November menu posted.
Saybrook Point's restaurant would return to an old use
The biggest food project in town is also the largest version of this pattern. Before Tropical Storm Irene and then Hurricane Sandy damaged it, Dock & Dine stood at Saybrook Point for more than 70 years. The building was later demolished, and the 2.2-acre lot has been empty for nearly 14 years.
The plan the town has been reviewing this fall would bring a casual restaurant back to Saybrook Point inside the Duffy Pavilion at 155 College Street. The town's Saybrook Point FAQ describes it as a return to an earlier use, because the pavilion ran as the Sand Bar for 23 years, from 1966 to 1989. The proposal converts the pavilion into a 3,471-square-foot restaurant. It would have 113 indoor seats across a dining room and a three-season enclosure, and an outdoor patio with 87 more.
The project depends on a land swap. The town would take ownership of the former Dock & Dine parcel. In return, it would lease the land under the Duffy Pavilion for $1 a year on a 25-year term with three 25-year renewal options. The Connecticut Scoop reported that voters approved the swap on March 31 by 1,993 to 726. The applicant is The Point, LLC, and local coverage names restaurateur Jon Kodama with the deal.
The restaurant has moved through town review this fall:
- On August 19, the Planning Commission voted 4 to 1 to send a favorable recommendation to Zoning.
- At the October 19 hearing, the Zoning Commission asked the applicant to cut 17 outdoor seats, document parking and drive-aisle dimensions, show a landscape-area calculation, and send the plans to the Town Engineer for review.
- On November 2, Zoning voted unanimously to continue the hearing to its Monday, November 16 meeting.
The town's FAQ projects that the restaurant could be operating about six months after it is approved, which would put a first season on the water sometime in 2027. For the former Dock & Dine lot itself, the town has proposed a public recreation area and plans to ask residents for ideas.
The walk around the restaurant site is changing too. A 2024 CT DEEP grant pays for a riverfront walkway running a full mile from Gardiner's Landing Park to the end of the causeway. On October 28, the town's waterfront committee recommended Weston & Sampson as the consultant for that work. The FAQ's own description of the Point holds in any season, including winter: "there is always someone at the Point," walking, fishing, eating ice cream, or "eating in their cars."
Spencer Plains Road is getting new tenants
Spencer Plains Road is where Old Saybrook's food scene is taking on new names. In late September, The Connecticut Scoop reported that Jersey Mike's had leased a 1,300-square-foot unit at 22 Spencer Plains Road in Max's Place, and that Chipotle had also signed as a tenant there. Both are lease announcements so far, with opening dates still to come.
Next door, at 20 Spencer Plains Road, Sal's Pizza & Pasta announced in August that it would close on August 23 after 32 years in business, 19 of them in Old Saybrook and 13 in Westbrook. If those leases go ahead, two national chains will join a road where a family pizza place had been part of the town's routine for nearly two decades.
The tables that stay set through New Year's
Several Old Saybrook kitchens are seasonal. Liv's Shack at 26 Bridge Street runs from May through September. Its sister restaurant, Liv's Oyster Bar at 166 Main Street, serves dinner from 4 p.m. Tuesday through Friday and from 5 p.m. on Saturday, and it is closed Sunday and Monday. Its 4 to 5:30 p.m. weekday happy hour has discounted clams and a featured oyster.
Fresh Salt at Saybrook Point Resort & Marina, 2 Bridge Street, says it serves breakfast, lunch, dinner and Sunday brunch year-round. Lunch and dinner run 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. most days and until 9:30 on Friday and Saturday. The Sunday Lobster Eggstravaganza brunch is back, with lobster at no extra charge. The resort's special events page also lists these dates:
- Thanksgiving buffet, Thursday, November 26, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., reservations required
- Brunch with Santa on Sundays, November 29, December 6 and December 13, 10:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., at $69.95 per adult and $34.95 per child
- Christmas Day dinner buffet, Friday, December 25, 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., reservations required
- The Time & Tide New Year's Eve Gala, Thursday, December 31, 7 p.m. to 12:30 a.m.
If you are hosting Thanksgiving at home, Pasta Vita on Elm Street is taking catering orders until Saturday, November 21, at 4 p.m. Pickup is Tuesday, November 24, or Wednesday, November 25, by 3 p.m., and the store is closed on Thanksgiving Day. The full Thanksgiving menu is on the shop's site.
The December night to book ahead is Saturday, December 12. The Old Saybrook Torchlight Parade steps off at 6 p.m., with fife-and-drum corps, floats and Santa. It falls the night before the last Santa brunch at Fresh Salt, so a family can plan both into one weekend. The James is open until 6 p.m. that Saturday, so sandwiches picked up on Main Street can carry a family through the parade, and Liv's starts Saturday dinner at 5 p.m. For more on how the town's fall and winter calendar fills up, see our look at Old Saybrook's busiest weeks after summer, and our Old Saybrook neighborhood guide covers the rest of town.
A restaurant returning to Saybrook Point and new life at 323 Main Street are the kind of local detail the Nancy Mesham Team brings to every pricing conversation. If you live near the Point or within walking distance of Main Street and want to know what your home is worth this winter, we're glad to prepare a valuation for you.